Credit Markets Eye Automation

Industry leaders who attended a market summit on over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives operations in London are urging major credit derivatives dealers to band together and form a central clearing agent to clean up a market where regulators want to see transaction processing become more automated.

The service could be based upon a structure similar to SwapClear, which was launched in September 1999 by London-based clearinghouse LCH.Clearnet to provide clearing for plain vanilla OTC interest rate swaps, according to the panel of three senior representatives from the buy side and sell side and an industry clearing and settlement service.

"Any one of the major prime brokers [in the credit derivatives market] could take that leap of faith and suggest operating a clearing house," says Chris Bentley, head of operations at London-based hedge fund Cairn Capital, which manages portfolios worth $30 billion. "This could potentially be done just for their clients to start off with and if this started a precedent, others may join to form a consortium of banks operating the system. This will reduce the logistics of confirmation matching payments. You would give all your trades to the clearinghouse and match them off," he adds.

Major dealers in the credit derivatives market—which include Bank of America, Citi, Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan—have already taken steps to make transaction processing more automated, such as confirming a higher percentage of trades electronically and adopting new functionality from electronic clearing and settlement firms such as the New York-based Depository Trust & Clearing Corp. (DTCC).

The big backlog in unconfirmed trades in the credit derivatives market—which stemmed from manual processes at banks with some dealers still using pieces of paper to register trades—first fell under regulatory scrutiny in September 2005 when Timothy Geithner, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, spearheaded a drive to clean up the backoffice processes of 14 of the largest dealers in the market. The 14 banks have since reduced backlogs on outstanding confirmations by more than 80 percent.

However, Val Wotton, vice president, equity derivative and structured products documentation at Citigroup, points out that investment firms will face further technical challenges if they are to integrate their trade processing systems with an external clearing agent.

"There are issues around matching workflow and your internal workflow management. How do you actually internally control your documents and your payments and then leading on from there, how do you then process them to an industry client solution such as one provided by SwapClear. There are also questions around how you link back into your internal systems and close the loop," says Wotton.

New York-based electronic brokerage Creditex's credit derivatives trade processing platform T-Zero—which offers market participants a messaging system for the electronic affirmation of credit default swap trades—was also suggested by the summit panel as a possible centralized clearing agent in the future.

However, Bill Hodgson, first vice president derivatives services at the DTCC, says the fragmented buy-side market presents a challenge to the development of "focused" buy-side services. "It is not hard to build a platform. Getting people to use it is a different matter," he says.

"An integrated approach needs 300 buy-side firms to come to the table. Unless there is some form of an industry forum for the buy side [to express their view] we are not going to have that," says Bentley.

Hodgson says the exchange and cash markets have taken decades to formulate integrated trade processing systems. "Generally, firms buy solutions that plug into their food chain. In derivatives, SwapClear and T-Zero have bits of the food chain. Even though we are working quickly on the trade information warehouse for credit, I think it will be quite some years before you see a mature and comprehensive global settlement solution that is integrated across all OTC asset classes by one provider," he says.

Meanwhile, global regulators continue to monitor the infrastructure used by major industry dealers to process equity, interest rate and commodity derivatives. The New York Fed announced in May that 18 major market participants in the equity derivatives market had made progress in automating post-trade processing infrastructure. Dealers have succeeded in reducing equity derivatives confirmation backlogs by 25 percent in the period from November 2006 to Jan. 31 of this year.

Source - http://www.watersonline.com/public/showPage.html?page=457137
Publish date - July 1, 2007